Saturday, May 17, 2008

Childish superstitions and atheists really pissed Einstein off

Or at least that’s the impression I get when reading parts of a letter he wrote in 1954 which just got auctioned off for $404,000 in London (that’s nearly 1000 euros in European money, I think). Or maybe it’s just the fact that the letter was written in German. German often sounds so really pissed off, doesn’t it? Well it sure can in Berlin.

Anyway, returning from the grave isn’t easy for anyone I’m sure, but to do so just to slam religion like that (Hello? The afterlife?), well that’s certainly a first. But he was Einstein after all and if anyone can pull this one off, I guess he can. Not having much to offer for the traditionally faithful, he found the Bible to be childish, the idea of Jews being a chosen people silly (although they were a bit “protected from the worst cancers by a lack of power” - this was in 1954 like I said) and that although religion provided believers with a certain protective self-deception perhaps, it did not necessarily improve their morality.

None of this seems all that E=mc² these days, does it? What I find more refreshing is his attack upon atheism. Describing himself as an agnostic, Einstein scoffed at atheists as being people who do the same intolerance religious fanatics do. “They are creatures who - in their grudge against the traditional ‘opium for the people’ - cannot bear the music of the spheres.”

Maybe that’s why evolutionary biologist and world-class atheist Richard Dawkins was among the bidders for the letter (he lost out, of course, atheists are real cheapskates you know). He probably wanted to have the thing destroyed.

Meine Ansichten sind zu gewaltig für unseren bzw. euren begrenzten Geist.

Kommentare auf Deutsch? Logisch.

Posted by clarsonimus at 09:24:45 | Permanent Link | Comments (7) |
Comments
1 2
1 - Nah, Dakins lost the bidding because the auctioneers wouldn't accept the pound notes he bid with as he had taken a felt tip marker to all the images of Elizabeth II, as Supreme Governor of the CHurch of England and Defender of the Faith. Plus they became suspicious when he tried to change his currency while wearing latex gloves and a haz-mat suit. (Comment this)

Written by: Pat Patterson at 2008/05/17 - 11:28:10
2 - I have to disagree with Einstein on, '...atheists ... being people who do the same intolerance religious fanatics do'. Surely a regular atheist is only as fanatic in his certainty that god doesn't exist as a standard religious person is in his certainty that god does. Nothing fanatic about not believing. Unless believing is fanatic too.

BiB (Comment this)

Written by: Anonymous at 2008/05/17 - 12:44:06
3 - How many scientists does it take to establish that God does not exist? Answer: Zero, nil, none ! No proofs, just beliefs out there. . Therefore, the world comes down to believers and non-believers of what?. Each man and woman must decide alone on this issue. At the end it really won´t make any difference at all. Or did Einstein think his brilliance would impress anyone or anything in infinity? (Comment this)

Written by: Anonymous at 2008/05/17 - 18:08:06
4 - BiB, I wouldn't use the word fanatic either, but the word certainty is bad enough. That's what bothers me about both extremes, having or claiming to have that kind of certainty. (Comment this)

Written by: clarsonimus at 2008/05/18 - 19:45:57
5 - Anonymous, I agree. There's the practical intellect (reason?) and the contemplative intellect (intuition?) and never the twain will meet. (Comment this)

Written by: clarsonimus at 2008/05/18 - 19:49:27
Write a comment






1 2