Monday, September 24, 2007

German to prove America sucks once and for all

“I used to think America was dreadful,” says German media artist Florian Thalhofer. “But now I’m going to actually prove just how sucky it is.” “And I’m going to tell everybody all of the awful things they think they already know about Germany,” says his American counterpart Mark Simon. “Not that anybody out there could care less or anything.”



The two touchingly naive artist types are planning to spend their own kind of biblical 40 days in the desert, traveling through their respective enemy territories on a quest for something they like to call “authenticity”. Worse still, they are actually going to film all of this nonsense and show it to others outside their close circle of friends or immediate family.

An authentically bad idea, anybody out there who has ever taken a step outside his own Dorf or cow town already knows what the two will find: Thalhofer will come to the realization that authentic Americans really are loud, pushy, superficial, overweight and under-cultured while Simon is doomed to discover that Germans are authentically pedantic and aggressive, obsessed with order, speed on the autobahn, watch way too much soccer and really do drink lots of beer and eat tons of bratwurst.

And this idea isn’t terribly authentic, either. This type of America/Germany bashing thing has been done before. In fact, it gets done every day of the week. It’s called “the news”, or die Nachrichten, if you prefer. And you can’t change channels, either. Not really. You can only change countries, or deserts, if you prefer.

Sind Sie ein echter Amerikaner, oder bloß ein wahrer?

Kommentare auf Deutsch? Logisch.

Posted by clarsonimus at 08:00:20 | Permanent Link | Comments (8) |
Comments
1 2
1 - I'm beginning to thing you're the brains - if you can actually call it that - behind David's Medienkritik. He slags anything produced for public consumption in Germany as a direct slur on all things American. Worse, if he can't find one, or get one of his paying readers / dupes to send one in - he'll speculate on what the German reporter MIGHT have said against America had he been given the opportunity.

This post smacks of exactly that. Give them a chance to make their film before you go off criticizing it. (Comment this)

Written by: letters at 2007/09/24 - 09:06:17
2 - letters, I was kind of sort of joking, you know? The idea itself is actually quite interesting and I hope they have a lot of fun doing it. I’m just very skeptical about any kind of Verständigung/understanding they hope to achieve. People don’t believe things if you prove them wrong (like this guy might be trying to do), people believe the things they want to believe, period. And they will do this despite the fact that you might prove them wrong. That’s why Germans don’t like America. They don’t want to like America. It’s that simple. And no, I don’t have anything to do with David’s Medienkritik, unfortunately. I like that site, as you know. And I really don’t see why you don’t like it. They just reprint what the Germans put out there. You can’t get much more objective than that. Or could it be that you just don’t WANT to like it?? <;-) To each his own, I say. Everyone believes what the want to believe in the end anyway. (Comment this)

Written by: clarsonimus at 2007/09/24 - 17:49:27
3 - The thing about Medienkritik is, they scrape the bottom of the barrel. I mean come on, if German media was so anti-American, he'd be having to sift through a huge pile of anti-American articles every day to find the best one. Instead he searches high and low for something - anything - BEGS his readers to send in scraps and tidbits he can blow all out of proportion. Then he regurgitates the SAME old rant every post and when he has nothing to post about, he speculates on what the Germany media MIGHT have said on such-and-such - all against America, of course.

I think you should feel happy not to be associated with it. It's pure trash.

At least you have your tongue planted firmly in your cheek - something I forgot. Or did I want to forget? ;-) (Comment this)

Written by: letters at 2007/09/24 - 19:44:05
4 - Some Germans have always been critical of America, but it has been a love/hate type of thing. On the one hand there was the mystique of America, the ideals which you can read out of the Bill of Rights or the Constitution, the respect for the individual, a form of government that tried to assure these ideals. But those ideals are gone now, and all that's left are the things that are truly ugly about America. So I would that films like this go with the territory. (Comment this)

Written by: Indeterminacy at 2007/09/25 - 05:44:31
5 - Indeterminacy, I can't agree with that, of course. The ideals are not gone and that's the problem. The ideals are what make us strong. And THAT is what the Germans (and all the others) don't like. The Germans only "like" us when we're weak or wounded (think 9/11). When we do something about it - and we always do - they start moaning and bashing again. The ideals are missing someplace else, I'm afraid. Think Realpolitik. That is a term that still actually has a positive ring to it here. (Comment this)

Written by: clarsonimus at 2007/09/25 - 08:03:36
Write a comment






1 2