Thursday, April 26, 2007

Gun control still working here

The big Empörung (outrage) about last week’s shooting in Virginia, followed by the obligatory lecturing on the antiquated American Wild West back wood’s attitude concerning gun control there hardly had a chance to die down before somebody else gets blown away by a heavily-armed criminal here, in Germany, again. This happens all the time over here by the way, it’s just that the Empörung part is usually missing.

A policewoman was murdered by some creep in Heilbronn while she was routinely checking papers within the framework of that city’s “Secure City” initiative. Her partner was also shot and may not make it, either. Nothing like this ever happens in small cities over here, you see. But then it does doch (after all) and nobody really seems to get hot and bothered about it. If, however, the same thing happens in an American city, that incident has a good chance of making German front page news.

The logic is quite simple really: Because we are German, everything is Friede, Freude, Eierkuchen (law and orderly) and criminal acts are just that. In America though, the fact that practically anyone can arm his or herself is, in and of itself, criminal. In America you are guilty without charge, before anything even happens. And if nothing happens, that’s the exception.

But that criminals do pretty much what they want to do regardless of the law is what makes them criminals, you see. And it doesn’t really matter which country they find themselves in, either. And a little more Empörung about that might be in order. Before the next shooting, I mean. No simple solutions there, oder (or are there)?

Think prison sentences, for instance. Your short, vacation-style ones don't seem to work, either. It’s a vicious circle, isn’t it?

Schon wieder etwas Ungewöhnliches.

Kommentare auf Deutsch? Klar.

PS: Thanks for the Japanese fake guns link, Kurt - and the eject link, too. Damn, Kurt won't stop! Thanks for the cool fun facts and quotes link, too.

PPS: And thanks for those two links, too, letters.

Posted by clarsonimus at 07:43:39 | Permanent Link | Comments (30) |
Comments
1 2 3 4 5 6
1 - For sure, criminals will do what they want no matter what the means, but that's no excuse for maintaining overly lax gun laws.

In Hong Kong you can get years in prison if you are caught with bullets but no gun. Since there are few guns around, many murders are committed with meat cleavers, a common tool in the Cantonese kitchen. But every time there is a chopper murder splashed on the front page you don't hear calls for every one of the seven million HK residents to go around packing meat cleavers for self-defence as you did in the wake of the Virginia shootings, when many claimed if more people had been packing heat in the classroom the massacre wouldn't have happened. (Comment this)

Written by: letters at 2007/04/26 - 14:39:25
2 - letters, that is very true. Unfortunately, however, nothing will ever change in the States because the gun lobbey (ie: NRA) have such a stranglehold on Washington. It also does not help that the Senate is structurally skewed towards the Western states. This is due to the fact that the sparsely populated Western states (which are, historically, more pro-gun than the Eastern and Northern states) have the same leverage in the Senate (every one gets two votes, no matter how many people). While it can be easier to get gun-control legislation through the House of Reps, it is nearly impossible to get similar bills through the Senate, which makes it very nearly impossible to get gun-control legislation to the President.

People will fume about guns for a while and then it will all fade out. Just like it did after all of the other school shootings that have happened since Columbine (and before). A very sad, but unfortunately true, fact of current American society and government. (Comment this)

Written by: emh at 2007/04/26 - 17:04:09
3 - emh, I think what you (and letters) are saying is true, but I wouldn't go as far as to call it sad. Sad is that people are so mixed up and lost. Guns have a lot to do with identity in the US and, in the end, a long history of not trusting the government "evil", whether it is in fact evil or not. But like letters said, you can go out there and kill people with a kitchen knife if you want to. Is that sad? Sure it is - that a person would do such a thing. But it's not the knife's fault. And that's why I don't think that regulation (evil government again) can ever effectively stop people from hurting themselves. They seem to like doing it too much. (Comment this)

Written by: Clarsonimus at 2007/04/26 - 19:56:01 in reply to: 2
4 - Clarsonimus, ok, so, sad is not exactly the right word... maybe a better word would be some what depressing (at least to me) and maybe distressing. But it is true, people will be people, and people will continue hurting people, ad infinitum. (Comment this)

Written by: emh at 2007/04/26 - 20:44:51 in reply to: 3
5 - letters, I would think that in Hong Kong there also wouldn't be calls for tougher meat cleaver laws either. Japan has gun laws that make Germany look like the wild west. Yet, the recent shooting of the mayor of Nagasaki (over pothole damage to a gangsters car, no less) shows that you can pass all the laws the laws you want and criminals will still somehow get their hands on guns. While, it's impossible to (legally) get a gun in Japan, you can easily get incredibly realistic looking fake guns:

http://www.tokyo-marui.co.jp/index2.html (Comment this)

Written by: Kurt In NYC at 2007/04/27 - 06:47:42
Write a comment






1 2 3 4 5 6